Neoseeker : News : 'mediawatch-uk' tries to ban MadWorld, gamers say 'shut the f*** up'

'mediawatch-uk' tries to ban MadWorld, gamers say 'shut the f*** up'
Sean Ridgeley - Wednesday, November 12th, 2008 | 10:34AM (PT) 0 Like


"This game sounds very unsavoury..."

Self-appointed watchdog group 'mediawatch-uk' is still exerting its influence to try to refuse the violent Wii game MadWorld classification, thereby banning it from sale. Here's what the group's director John Beyer had to say:

"This game sounds very unsavoury.  I hope the British Board of Film Classification (BBFC) will view this with concern and decide it should not be granted a classification.  Without that it cannot be marketed in Britain.  We need to ensure that modern and civilized values take priority rather than killing and maiming people.  It seems a shame that the game's manufacturer has decided to release this game exclusively on the Wii.  I believe it will spoil the 'fun for all the family' image of the Wii."

Does this guy play games? Or violent games? Highly doubtful. If not, why is he trying to ban them? I don't go to Hollywood Records and  try to get the Jonas Brothers records banned cause I think it's corrupting our children (tempting as it might be). And what's with the double standard? It sounds like if the game was on the PS3 and/or 360, they wouldn't care a bit.

Apparently I'm not the only one who finds this ridiculous, as mediawatch-uk reports:

"Within hours of these remarks being published a rain of hostile emails from gamers poured into our office telling us to "shut the f*** up", suggesting that we have "got our knickers in a twist", demanding, as though we were on trial for an heinous crime, to know what right we had to impose our "narrow minded bigotry" on them and stopping them playing an "adult" game of their choice. 

Others, of a more sober character, asked reasonably why we should be so concerned about games when there was so much violence in films and on television!  We were also accused us of being "cowards" for not responding properly to belligerent strictures and one ‘emailer' observed glibly that "violent acts are not a symptom of video games and films, but rather the human condition".  Another said: "If you don't like violent content, don't view or use it". 

Others thanked us cynically for drawing attention to the game saying they would rush out and buy it as soon as it was available.  Yet others told us to focus on retailers and said that parents should safeguard their children from "adult" games."

They also remind the BBFC (their ratings board) received "abusive and incoherent" protests from gamers who disagreed with their decision to reject the game Manhunt II - a decision that was subsequently overturned on appeal."

It's time like this I remember exactly why I love the gaming industry so much. Gamers, bless your little hearts.


'mediawatch-uk' tries to ban MadWorld, gamers say 'shut the f*** up' Image 1
  • 0 thumbs!
    | Nov 12, 08
    It's funny you know, these folks discount complaints, simply because they don't agree with the way it was phrased. Bottom line, and any censor association is going to run into this. The failure is not the gaming industry, it's parents, and the stores that sell these games to children. Adults, are more than capable of deciding for themselves, whether or not a violent game is appropriate for them. However, children require oversight. If you don't provide that, then the children will use their best judgement (which is none). Blaming society, for your failures as a parent, is typical of families this day and age. And not just in the UK, we American's have this issue too. Parents need to take responsibility for their children. Period.


    Morne
  • 0 thumbs!
    ViperSean since Apr 2002 | Nov 12, 08
    quote
    I believe it will spoil the 'fun for all the family' image of the Wii.
    That image is one of the bigger hurdles the Wii needs to overcome, TBH. "Fun for all the family" is always taken to imply "at the same time," which kind of undermines the "all the family" part in the first place - no one always wants to play with their family. Some have gotten the impression that the Wii is 100% to the sugar-coated, family-friendly thing, which isn't the case at all. The Wii is intended to have universal appeal - that means both ends of the spectrum, as well as everywhere in between. Unfortunately, the scale's tipped so far to one side - titles like No More Heroes could only do so much to try and balance it out; we need more games like MadWorld (and NMH:Desperate Struggle, natch) to help widen the Wii's repertoire.
  • 0 thumbs!
    chautemoc since Mar 2008 | Nov 12, 08
    Aptly said, Morne!

    Agreed, ViperSean. Personally I'm happy Nintendo agreed to release this one, and even remotely similar titles. They could easily not release anything like this and still be rich off their arses I'm sure..
  • 0 thumbs!
    kspiess since Jun 2007 | Nov 12, 08
    I'm fairly tired of the whole 'ban violent games movement.' I think it is largely motivated by baby-boomers who mistakenly believe that only kids play games, so there should be no violent games.

    I think the issue will disappear eventually, when the people who grew up with video games get into positions of policy making power. Once games make much more than movies do, the economic imperative will take over and the issue will also be squashed.

    If anyone is going to argue against violence in any games or any other medium, that could be tough. It is not exactly an easy task for a bunch of people in a watchdog group to change global cultural values, that have been evolving for thousands of years -- I wish them good luck with that.
  • 0 thumbs!
    ShadowJ since Jan 2003 | Nov 13, 08
    I say we throw these guys into an arena with a butter knife and a sheet of tin foil as weapons and pit them against the angry mob of gamers with guns then say to them

    "Ok stop this angry mob from killing you without the use of violence"

    Then quietly watch them crap themselves and wishing they actually played violent games in order to combat those that would literally strafe, jump & duck etc.

    In all seriousness, I had wondered how long it would take for Britain to begin becoming more PC and jumping on the bandwagon of "if we can complain and sue then why not"

    Then again I suppose "someone" has to take over the job of Jack Thompson, gamers need to hate someone
  • 0 thumbs!
    chautemoc since Mar 2008 | Nov 13, 08
    It's fun in a way but I'd sooner have away with it..I feel for Aussies and Brits who have to put up with the censorship and banning..
- This news story is archived and is closed to new comments now -

Hardware Newsletter:
Email:



Compare Prices

Motherboards
Abit
ASUS
Gigabyte
MSI
eVGA
Intel
Tyan
More...

Processors
AMD
Intel
More...

Memory
DDR
DDR2
DDR3
More...

Video Cards
ATI
eVGA
XFX
BFG
Sapphire
More...

search for lowest prices
(0.3805/mc/ascension)